Many older Indianapolis neighborhoods are still served by combined sewers that carry storm water and sewage in one pipe, so heavy rain can push wastewater back into basements. If sewage comes up, keep out, stop using water, and treat everything it touched as contaminated.
Key takeaways
- Combined sewers still serve many older Indianapolis neighborhoods and can overflow with as little as a quarter inch of rain.
- DigIndy is a 28-mile network of 18-foot tunnels about 250 feet deep, built under a 2006 federal consent agreement to eliminate 97 percent of combined sewer overflow.
- Whether basement backups have fallen since the tunnels opened was not sourced, and this guide does not claim they have.
- Sewage is the most contaminated water category, so porous material it soaked is usually removed rather than dried.
- Stop using water in the house during a backup, because every flush and drain adds to what is coming up.
- Marion County has excluded cities with their own governments, so which office answers a sewer question depends on where the house stands.
Why does sewage come up in basements in older Indianapolis neighborhoods?
In a combined sewer, storm water and household waste share one pipe. When rain fills the pipe faster than it drains, the pressure can push water back up the lateral and out of the lowest drain in a house.
Many older parts of Indianapolis were built when it was normal to send everything into one set of pipes. Modern systems separate storm water from sewage, but combined sewers remain in many older neighborhoods. When the rain is heavy enough, the pipe can overflow, and the same surge that spills at the outfalls can back up into homes. Reports put the threshold as low as a quarter inch of rain, which is a small storm.
The lowest opening usually takes the water first: a basement floor drain, a laundry sink, a shower stall or a toilet. That is why sewage in a basement often shows up during a storm, not a pipe failure. The cause is capacity in the system, not something you did, though a blocked lateral in your own line can produce a backup on a dry day.
What is DigIndy and does it fix backups?
DigIndy is a 28-mile network of 18-foot tunnels about 250 feet deep, built under a 2006 EPA and Justice Department consent agreement. Its target is to eliminate 97 percent of combined sewer overflow.
The first 10-mile segment opened in December 2017. The utility reported over 500 million gallons kept out of the White River and Eagle Creek by late 2018 and later 1 billion gallons. The 28-mile system was celebrated as complete in October 2025, and the utility expects up to about 6 billion gallons a year to be prevented. The 6 billion is an expectation, not a measured result.
What it has not been shown to do is reduce basement backups. That question was not sourced, and the tunnels are designed to capture overflow that would otherwise reach rivers, not to protect an individual basement. A backup on your street can still come from a local pipe, a lateral or a neighborhood sewer that the tunnel does not touch. Treat the project as river protection, and plan for your own house on its own terms.
Neighbors on the same block often learn about a backup at the same moment, since a surcharge in a shared main reaches every low drain on that stretch. If your street has a pattern of this, write down the dates and the weather, and note which drains were affected. A log like that helps a plumber, the utility and an insurance adjuster understand whether you have a lateral problem or a neighborhood one, and it costs nothing to keep.
What should you do the moment sewage appears?
Stop using water, keep people and pets out, and avoid contact. Turn off power to the area if water is near outlets, but only if you can do it from a dry spot.
Every toilet flush, sink and washing machine sends more water into the line, and a line that is already backing up has nowhere to take it. Tell everyone in the house to stop using water until you know what is happening. Keep children and pets away from the affected area, and do not walk through it barefoot.
Photograph the water and the drain it came from. Open a window if the smell is strong, but do not try to wash it away with a hose. If it is a short, small backup and you have to enter, wear waterproof boots, gloves and a mask. Anything more than a small spill is a job for a crew, since sewage is the most contaminated water a house can take on.
Why is sewage treated differently from clean water?
Sewage carries bacteria and other contaminants, so the scope shifts from drying to removal and sanitizing. Porous material it touched is usually discarded.
Clean water from a failed supply line can often be dried in place. Sewage cannot. Carpet, pad, insulation, the lower run of drywall and soaked cardboard are generally removed and bagged. Hard surfaces are cleaned and treated, and the area is dried only after the contamination is dealt with.
This matters for your choices. Using a household fan to dry a sewage-wet floor spreads contaminants. Treating the problem as a normal basement leak underestimates the work. A crew will confirm the category on site, and that confirmation sets the plan.
How do you tell a sewer backup from a basement storm flood?
Look at where and how the water entered. Water rising through a floor drain or toilet, with odor and discoloration, points to the sewer. Water seeping through walls or the floor joint points to groundwater.
In Indianapolis the two often occur together during a storm, which is why people confuse them. A basement can take groundwater at the wall joint and sewage at the floor drain in the same hour. The smell and the color of the water are clues, but neither is definitive, and the safe assumption is that water from a drain is contaminated.
When you describe the loss, say where you first saw water. That detail changes how the work is scoped. It also affects insurance conversations, because backup coverage is often treated separately from other water losses on a policy, and this guide cannot say what yours includes.
Who is responsible for the pipe that backed up?
It depends on where the blockage or failure is. The lateral from your house to the main is generally the owner's concern, while the main under the street belongs to the utility or the municipality.
A backup caused by a root-blocked lateral on your property is usually your repair. A surcharge in a shared main during a storm is a utility matter. The distinction is not always clear from the basement, so a camera inspection of the lateral can tell you which one you are dealing with.
Marion County also contains excluded cities, namely Beech Grove, Lawrence, Southport and Speedway, which keep their own mayor and council. If you live in one of them, a sewer question may go to a different office than if you live in the consolidated city. Check the local government website for your address before assuming.
What does cleanup involve after a sewage backup?
Extraction of standing water, removal of porous material, cleaning and treatment of surfaces, and structural drying with moisture readings to confirm the result.
Crews remove the standing water first, then take out carpet, pad and any drywall or insulation the sewage reached. Surfaces left in place are cleaned and treated. Only then does the drying begin, with air movers and dehumidifiers and readings taken on each visit.
Ask for the scope in writing so you know what was removed and what was treated. Ask also about odor control after the work, because sewage smell can linger in masonry. Rebuild comes last, after the readings confirm the framing is dry.
Expect the work to be noisy and disruptive for a day or two, since removal and cleaning come before the drying equipment goes in. Plan to be out of the affected level until the surfaces are treated and the crew says the area is safe. Keep a note of what was discarded, because that list supports any claim you make later.
Can you reduce the chance of another backup?
Some measures help, though none can guarantee. A backwater valve on the lateral, a clean lateral and care about what goes down the drain all lower the risk.
A backwater valve closes when flow reverses, keeping sewage in the main. It needs to be installed correctly and maintained, and a plumber can advise whether your house is suited. A camera inspection tells you whether roots or breaks are creating the trouble.
Keep floor drains clear and avoid storing valuables on a basement floor in a house with a known backup history. For flooring, hard surfaces are easier to clean than carpet if the basement is prone to this problem. Nothing here is a promise, and your plumber is the one who can assess your line.
Frequently asked questions
Is sewer backup the city's fault?
Not necessarily. A surcharge in a shared sewer during a storm is a system issue, but a blocked lateral on your property is generally the owner's responsibility. A camera inspection can tell which applies. Because Marion County has excluded cities with separate governments, the office to ask depends on your address.
Has DigIndy stopped basement backups?
That was not sourced. DigIndy is built to capture combined sewer overflow before it reaches the rivers, and it is a 28-mile tunnel system completed in October 2025. Nothing found for this guide shows whether basement backups have fallen. Plan for your own house as if the risk remains.
Can I clean up a small sewage backup myself?
A very small spill on a hard floor may be handled with gloves, boots, a mask and a disinfectant, with the area kept clear of children and pets. Anything that reached carpet, drywall or a larger area should go to a crew. Do not use fans to dry sewage-wet material.
Does homeowners insurance cover sewer backup?
It depends on the policy, and backup coverage is often an add-on or has separate terms. Read yours or ask your insurer. If a dispute remains after you contact the insurer, the Indiana Department of Insurance takes written complaints, but it cannot set the value of a claim.
How quickly does sewage need to be removed?
As fast as a crew can be dispatched, since contamination spreads into porous material and odors set in. This site cannot promise an arrival time. In the meantime, stop using water, keep people out and photograph the damage. Call (833) 490-5225 to describe the situation.
Sources
- National Weather Service Indianapolis
- NOAA National Water Prediction Service
- Indiana Department of Insurance
- Wikipedia: Indianapolis
This guide is general information for Marion County homeowners, not a substitute for an on-site inspection. Prices are estimates. See our disclaimer.