How high has Fall Creek gone in recent record?
NWS gauge pages report a December 2013 crest of 10.4 feet at Fortville, believed to be the highest since March 1913. The Millersville gauge lists a record stage of 16.3 feet, though no date is given for it. Those are upstream gauges, not readings for your street.
Fortville and Millersville are both on Fall Creek, but they are not in Indianapolis proper, and the numbers are best read as signs of how large the creek can get, not as a forecast for a given neighborhood. The more useful local idea is that a creek which reached a level not seen since 1913 can do it again with the right rain.
This page does not give a figure for the 2008 crest, because no source for it was found. If you want a current reading, the NWS river page for the nearest gauge is the right place.
Which Indianapolis neighborhoods sit near Fall Creek?
Meridian-Kessler is the neighborhood most closely tied to Fall Creek, with the creek on its southern edge. The creek then continues southwest through Marion County to the White River. Each address has its own ground level, so a walk through the property decides the risk.
Meridian-Kessler is known for large early-twentieth-century houses on tree-lined streets, many with full basements. Those basements are the lowest part of the building and the first place water goes.
Older houses also tend to have older plumbing and floor drains, and a flooded basement can mix creek water with a drain backup. That would shift the job toward the sewage procedure.
Is creek water the same as sewage?
No, but both are handled as contaminated. Creek water carries mud and runoff; sewage carries pathogens from the sewer line. Which one you have changes the cleaning method and what materials can be kept, so the crew checks where the water came from before removal begins.
If the water arrived through a floor drain, or smells of sewage, it is treated under the sewer backup protocol. If it arrived through a door or a window well, it is creek water. A mix is possible during big storms.
The difference is also useful to an insurer. Policies tend to treat surface water, groundwater and sewer backup separately, so a note on how the water entered is part of a good record.
What should I do while waiting for the crew?
Stay out of standing water, keep power off to the wet area if you can reach the breaker safely, photograph the tide line, and lift small valuables onto dry surfaces. Do not run a gas generator indoors or try to pump the basement dry in one go.
Opening windows and running fans can help only after the standing water is out. Until then, the air is just moving humidity around.
If a pump is already running, leave it running. A working sump pump is a sign the system is trying to keep up, and it is covered on the sump pump failure page.